As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.
Fluoropolymer coatings were initially put to cookware using solvents like perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), as Leigh, our head of research, explained in her piece on the drawbacks of Teflon. Fluoropolymer coatings are often manufactured utilizing poly- and perfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS).
A significant lawsuit prevented Dupont and other manufacturers from using PFOA coatings in cookware after serious health effects were established.
Many PFAS are currently also prohibited from production due to the hazards of these “forever chemicals,” and the Biden administration intends to prohibit them from drinking water. It doesn’t follow, though, that outdated goods won’t still expose you to them.
A good method to reduce your exposure to PFAS is to stay away from most non-stick cookware, especially “green” versions. High heat might cause the coating on these pans to crack, potentially introducing undesired components into your stir fry.
| Image | Product Name | Editor's Rating | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
 | Caraway Cream | Check Price | |
 | Lodge 8 Inch | Check Price | |
 | ZWILLING SYNCHKG076919 | Check Price | |
 | de Buyer 5610.26A | Check Price | |
 | Xtrema XT-99541 | Check Price |
Best Non Toxic Non Stick Pans Reviews
Although more recent Teflon pans make the claim to be PFOA-free, they still include other substances, like a PTFE coating, which is best avoided. Brands who advertise their products as PFOA-free yet nonetheless utilize PTFE coatings on their pots and pans are a big source of frustration for customers looking for truly non-toxic non-stick kitchenware. These goods were not included in our list.
Our selection of the top non-stick pans is very small—only five pans—but that is due to the popularity of “reliable” brands that advertise their products as “Teflon-free” despite the fact that the coatings are still created with PTFE.
1. Caraway Cream
This non-toxic fry pan has a Teflon-free (PTFE free) cooking area that is coated instead in a tough ceramic inside. It has an interior that is nonstick and can withstand high temperatures, allowing you to cook with less oil. The pan will heat up quickly due to its relatively thin construction, and its ceramic coating should sustain heavy use without being damaged.
Note from Leigh: Caraway is an excellent, openly disclosed cookware company that tests all of its goods by a third party and sends everything in environmentally friendly containers free of single-use plastics. Additionally, it is induction compatible, allowing you to utilize this cookware on the most effective cooktops!
We didn’t consider the pan’s recommendation for lower heat settings to be a disadvantage. Overall, we adore Caraway as a unique company that produces exquisite goods without compromising on safety. The 100% PFOA and PTFE free non-stick that Caraway provides gives us the piece of mind we’re seeking for with non-toxic non-stick.
To be genuinely non-stick, the Caraway frying pan does need a tiny bit of oil, but we had no trouble sautéing a salmon filet without any skin sticking to the pan’s bottom.
2. Lodge 8 Inch
For a very good reason, Lodge has long held the top spot in the market for cast iron skillets. For years, the company has offered inexpensive, long-lasting cookware made in the USA; with proper maintenance, each item should survive for many generations.
Every Lodge cast iron pan is pre-seasoned and ready to use when it arrives at your door. Although its cooking surface is naturally nonstick, you need still use cooking oil for the majority of foods.
The Chef Collection skillet outperforms the company’s entry-level model thanks to additional features that make cooking simpler. This consists of an ergonomic handle, side pour spouts for easier handling of sauces and gravies, and slanted sidewalls for easier spatula stirring. This pan may be used almost everywhere, from a campfire to your induction stovetop, as is the case with all cast iron.
Remember to handle this pan gently when you clean it to avoid rust and preserve the seasoning layer. Never put it in the dishwasher or leave it damp.
3. ZWILLING SYNCHKG076919
Experience the Ultimate Cooking Performance with the Zwilling JA Henckels 66299-286 Madura Aluminum Fry Pan. This 11-inch fry pan is a kitchen essential for any home chef or cooking enthusiast.
Crafted with precision and expertise, the Madura Aluminum Fry Pan delivers exceptional heat distribution and retention. The durable aluminum construction ensures quick and even heating throughout the cooking surface, allowing for precise control over your culinary creations.
The non-stick coating on the interior of the pan provides effortless food release and easy cleanup, making it a breeze to cook delicate foods like eggs, fish, and more without worrying about sticking or residue.
Designed for comfort and convenience, the fry pan features an ergonomic handle that stays cool to the touch, ensuring a safe and comfortable grip while cooking. The stylish black exterior adds a touch of elegance to your kitchen.
Whether you’re searing, frying, or sautéing, the Zwilling JA Henckels Madura Aluminum Fry Pan is a reliable and versatile tool that will elevate your cooking experience. Enjoy professional-quality results with this exceptional fry pan and make every meal a culinary masterpiece.
4. de Buyer 5610.26A
Mineral B of the Buyer Pan has an almost nonstick surface, heats up rapidly, and is simple to handle. However, this pan loses points because it can only be used in the oven for brief periods of time and because seasoning is very difficult to keep up. PTFE, PFAS, and PFOA are not present in DeBuyer’s pans.
Despite being lighter than cast iron, this French-made pan can withstand intense heat just as well. Each pan can be used for baking, browning, sautéing, or even searing meat, and it is simple to transfer it from the cooktop to the oven. Note that the oven’s maximum cooking time at 400°F is only ten minutes.
The 99% pure iron cooking surface has a distinctive beeswax finish to aid in seasoning and lessen oxidation. Regular seasoning is necessary for its naturally nonstick surface, but with the appropriate maintenance, your pan should last for decades.
For anyone who enjoys using woks in the kitchen, it’s a wise option, and the pan becomes better with each usage. To avoid losing the seasoning, be sure you can commit to handwashing it.
5. Xtrema XT-99541
Although it is notable for its health safety and scratch resistance, this completely ceramic skillet is heavier, more delicate, and less nonstick than other selections on this list. PFAS, PFOA, and PTFE are absent from Xtrema.
One of the few companies selling just ceramic cookware is Xtrema. The skillet’s all-ceramic construction ensures that no contaminants will contaminate your food, but you may lose some performance as a result.
For instance, fragile items like eggs have a tendency to stick to it, and it cannot be used on induction stovetops. Additionally, the pan itself has a tendency to heat unevenly and the ceramic material is quite brittle at high temperatures.
Even if there is any sticking, this skillet is scratch-resistant and simple to clean. Additionally, Xtrema offers silicone grips for use with the skillet so that you may protect your hands when using it in the oven and microwave.
It suffices to mention that this is one of the greatest brands available if you’re determined to using only pure ceramic cookware.
The depth of the Xtrema skillet is something that is difficult to see in images. The pan can be utilized by home cooks for sautéing, frying, or even boiling a little amount of pasta. The pan has a lot of flexibility because of its depth. These pans are made to last if used properly.
They aren’t as non-stick as some rivals, though, so you’ll have to add some cooking oil to get full non-stick results. The reason to get Xtrema is for its extended lifespan and high level of transparency when it comes to safety and purity.
For pure non-stick functionality, other, more recent brands like Caraway have a tiny advantage, but it’s probable that Xtrema products will outlast them.
What To Look For in a Safe Non-stick Pan
Nonstick pans come in a variety of designs and are nontoxic. Here are the top non-toxic materials now in use.
Ceramic
This natural material can withstand high heat cooking since it is free of heavy metals, coatings, dyes, and polymers. Because ceramic cookware is suitable for use in the oven, freezer, dishwasher, and even the microwave, chefs adore it. Although the pans are prone to breaking at these temperatures, ceramic is thought to be the safest cookware for high heat (up to 2500°F).
Coated in ceramic
With ceramic-coated cookware, you may enjoy the advantages of ceramic cookware without the weight or cost. They provide an even heating surface, are non-reactive, and have a high heat tolerance (up to 600°F). However, the majority aren’t microwave-compatible, and the ceramic surface will ultimately become scratched.
Steel, carbon
Carbon steel has a seasoning coating that naturally makes it nonstick, just like your favorite cast iron pan. It is a superior option for frying pans and woks than cast iron since it is lighter, thinner, and heats up more quickly.
Although carbon steel is frequently inexpensive, it is highly robust and easy to clean. Just be aware that it is neither dishwasher or microwave safe.