As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.
Some of the top outdoor accessories available are made by the well-known American company Buck. Regardless of your requirements, Buck is certain to have the ideal knife for you.
The only thing left to do is choose between the 119 Special and the 124 Frontiersman since, since you’re reading this, I’d assume you already know quite a bit about Buck.
This essay seeks to clarify the distinctions so you can decide which one best fits your needs.
Which knife is better for me, the Buck 124 or the Buck 119? I’ll walk you through the features, cost, and actual user evaluations of each model to help you decide. (as well as if the Frontiersman is pricey enough).
Here are the main elements if you don’t have time to read the entire essay.
- The 124 will be your finest option if you’re looking for a sturdy knife that’s perfect for hunting and other sports like batoning.
- But choose the 119 if you want something a little bit smaller that is best suited for trickier outdoor jobs.
| Image | Product Name | Editor's Rating | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
 | Buck 124 | Check Price | |
 | Buck 119 | Check Price |
Key Comparisons Between the Buck 124 vs Buck 119
Even if these two knives are quite similar at first sight, it’s crucial to recognize the essential variations because they are what make the models suitable for various outdoor demands!
One of the greatest knives available for dedicated hunters, according to the 124. It is simple to understand why this large knife is excellent for hunters with large hands given its full tang, deep choil, and incorporated finger guard. This knife is excellent for batoning as well since it is a sturdy, multi-use type that will work well for you in more difficult chores.
The 119, on the other hand, is a somewhat smaller knife that works well for more intricate jobs like cutting in narrow spaces or doing precise work. This knife’s characteristics have been given considerable consideration. It feels solid and stable in your palm thanks to finger grooves on the handle’s belly and the metal pommel. Gratitude and harmony!
The 124 model is the heavier of the two knives, as you can guess from the information above. It works well for strenuous activities like batoning. It shouldn’t come as a surprise, though, that some individuals complain that the knife feels a little blocky in the hand due to its sturdy construction. The 119 model is significantly lighter. Numerous reviews note how satisfying and well-balanced this model is to hold.
Both items include a premium leather sheath with a snap closure, and the built-in belt loop makes it possible to carry the knife securely while you’re out and about. Both versions also come with a lifetime guarantee, as do all Buck goods. If it isn’t a sign of high caliber, we’re not sure what is!
Ultimately, we’d advise purchasing the Buck 124 if you require a larger knife or have a larger budget.
In either case, you’ll be receiving a top-notch knife from a reputable American manufacturer, and both will be useful to you when you’re having fun in the great outdoors. Why not adore it?
Just a fast summary; now, let’s get into the specifics.
Detailed View of Buck 124
The Buck 124 takes great satisfaction in being the ideal hunting blade. It would be a fantastic addition to your hunting bag because it is strong, resilient, and razor sharp.
A traditional hunting bowie knife is the Buck 124. It is a somewhat large knife at 11 3/4′′ long and 13.3 oz in weight, yet many big-handed reviewers gush about how great it feels in their hands.
Buck has included several innovative features despite the larger knife’s size to attempt to lessen the blocky sensation. To guarantee a secure grasp, the handle incorporates palm swells and curves.
The Micarta handle is another significant selling factor. Micarta is sturdy and long-lasting, and as it is resistant to many liquids, including rain, it allows for the safe use of the knife in bad weather.
Many customers express their appreciation for this knife’s full tang rather than rat-tail tang in their evaluations, demonstrating how popular the full tang design is. A full tang knife has the advantage of enabling greater power to be applied through the handle, which is excellent for demanding outdoor jobs.
The Buck 124’s blade, like other Buck knives, is composed of 420HC steel that has undergone a unique heat-treating procedure. This indicates that the knife is corrosion-resistant, sharper right out of the box, and keeps its edge longer.
Detailed View of Buck 119
A range of outdoor enthusiasts frequently choose the Buck 119. While it could struggle with heavier tasks, it excels when used for woodworking or cutting in confined spaces. Numerous reviews mention how well-balanced and functional the knife is, as well as how nice it looks and feels in the hand.
The Buck 119 weighs 7.5 oz, which is more manageable than the Buck 124’s 13.3 oz solid weight. However, as can be seen in the accompanying side-by-side stats table, the two models’ overall length, blade length, and thickness are really rather comparable.
The Buck 119 has no such issues, however some customers find the Buck 124 a bit awkward to grip. The specialists that designed this knife made sure that the model fit well in your hand. A knife that is comfortable to grip is promised by finger grooves, palm swells, and an aluminum pommel.
One of the Buck brand’s best-selling models, the Buck 119 is regarded as the ideal knife to pass down from generation to generation. It also comes with a leather sheath and a snap closure, just like many Buck knives. Many people mention how wonderful and authentic the leather smells!
The 119 is proudly crafted in the USA, just like all other Buck knives, and the company stands by the quality of their work by providing a lifetime warranty.
Buck 124 vs. Buck 119 in summary
After reading this post, maybe you’ll see why the owners of both the 124 and 119 like their vehicles.
What distinguishes the Buck 124 from the Buck 119? Both knives use Buck’s renowned Paul Bos Heat Treat technique, feature clip blades, and are handcrafted in the USA. The weight is the primary distinction between the two. The 119 is significantly lighter and better suited for more challenging jobs, while the 124 is a large knife that can handle heavy-duty outdoor chores.
You now know what you need from a knife, so consider the tasks you’ll probably use it for, and it should become evident whether you need a Buck 124 or Buck 119.
At Knives Advisor, we think the knives are distinct enough to warrant buying both to make sure you’re ready for any task! If you don’t want to add two knives to your shopping, the 120 would be a decent middle ground.